Question: Did Gollum Deserve To Die?

Is Sauron an elf?

Originally Answered: Is Sauron an elf.

No, he was a Maia of the race of the Ainur.

At the beggining, when Eru created the Ainur, he created 2 types of Ainur: The Valar, that had more innate power and understood better the aspects of Eru’s mind (each one of the Valar understood different aspects of Eru’s mind)..

Did Frodo kill Gollum?

Gollum does not slip and fall at the end of Lord of the Rings. Gollum is killed by Frodo using the magic of the One Ring. This climactic action by Frodo is omitted from the film adaptation.

Why did Gollum betrays Frodo?

Smeagol wants to trust him, but he remembers being “betrayed” by a Baggins years earlier. Frodo is also a Baggins, and Gollum tries to convince him that he is unreliable. Smeagol fails to see that Bilbo never intended to “betray” him: he was simply trying to survive.

Did Gollum eat babies?

Did Gollum eat orcs? Yes he did! We know that he killed and ate young orcs (goblins) for centuries when he lived beneath the Misty Mountains. The narrator tells us this in The Hobbit.

Who betrayed Frodo?

BoromirBoromir betrays Frodo in The Fellowship of the Ring.

How old is Gollum?

589The Lord of the Rings: Age of selected charactersCharacterAge in yearsGollum589Gimli140Bilbo129Denethor899 more rows•Nov 18, 2014

What race is Smeagol?


Did Gandalf die?

Gandalf made him this way. In the middle of the first Lord of the Rings novel, The Fellowship of the Ring, shortly after his pronouncement on death to Frodo, Gandalf dies. “I can’t explain the impact that had on me at 13,” Martin said in a recent interview with PBS. “You can’t kill Gandalf.

Why do hobbits carry the ring?

The hobbits aren’t immune to the ring, you can see that from the fact the Smeagol turned into Gollum, and also the way in which Bilbo was affected by it. The ring was created to enhance Sauron’s capacity to dominate Middle Earth and its nature was such that it would fuel an individuals desire to rule over others.

Why didn’t they kill Gollum?

He evaded capture and, drawn by Sauron’s evil, made his way to Mordor. There he was taken and tortured, and Sauron learned the fate of the One Ring and learned the names Baggins and Shire. Sauron made a great mistake, and did not kill Gollum.

Why did Bilbo not kill Gollum?

Bilbo didn’t kill Gollum just because he wanted to know the way to get out from the mountain. If he killed Gollum, there would be no one left underground, so he won’t be able to get out from the mountain. Although he had risk to play riddles because he may be eaten, but he mustn’t kill Gollum if he want to get out.

Is Gollum dangerous?

Smeagol is weak, cowardly, trapped, pitiful, whiny and miserable; Gollum (his split personality) is dangerous, murderous, dishonest, calculated, furious and manipulative. The character cannot be analyzed properly if he is considered one and the same because he is NOT- he is divided.

Why does Frodo think Gollum deserves death?

Frodo laments that his uncle Bilbo had not killed Gollum when he had the chance, saying that Gollum deserved to die for his “horrible deeds.” Gandalf replies: Deserves it! … Then do not be too eager to deal out death in judgment. For even the very wise cannot see all ends.

What race is Gandalf?


Who did Gollum kill?

cousin DéagolTA 2463 – Sméagol (later known as Gollum) becomes the fourth master of the One Ring, after killing his cousin Déagol.

How does Frodo die?

He bites Frodo’s finger off, along with the ring. Gollum is so happy that he starts to dance and jump and loses his footing and falls into the fire, thus destroying him and the ring. Later, the injured Frodo and Sam are rescued by the Eagle King from the side of Mount Doom. Answer has 7 votes.

What disorder does Gollum have?

Liz Sampson, concludes that Gollum was actually suffering from schizoid personality disorder. In the paper, Sméagol is described as a single, 587 year old, hobbit-like male of no fixed abode. He displays antisocial behaviour, increasing aggression, and preoccupation with the ‘one ring’.

Is Gollum good or evil?

He is not evil, conniving or malicious – these personality traits belong to Gollum, who should never be confused with Smeagol. “Smeagol would never dream of wielding power over those weaker than himself. He is not a bully. In fact he’s very lovable.

Is Gollum a villain?

Type of Villain Gollum, originally known as Sméagol or Trahald, is a creature of Hobbit origin and a major antagonist in J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-Earth legendarium. Gollum is one of the two secondary antagonists in the novel The Lord of the Rings (alongside Saruman), and a supporting antagonist in the novel, The Hobbit.

Why did smaug not kill Bilbo?

Smaug did not know that Bilbo had the one ring. Unlike the Nazgul, Smaug couldn’t detect the presence of the ruling ring. He had no way of knowing that Bilbo had it, was using it, or that it was the power of the ring that made it impossible for Smaug to find Bilbo. Smaug’s fire could not destroy the one ring.

Was Gollum tortured?

On the other hand, Gollum was so far into the Shadow that they might have been able to smell it, while he was sneaking around Barad-dur and Orodruin. … He was taken to Sauron, who tortured Gollum himself.