Question: Why Does Gandalf Let Go?

Did Gandalf know that Bilbo had the ring?

No.

Gandalf certainly did not realise that Bilbo’s ring was the One Ring at the end of The Hobbit, or indeed by the start of The Lord of the Rings.

The realisation came upon him slowly, and he only fully worked it out years after the start of The Lord of the Rings.

“How long have you known all this?” asked Frodo again..

Why didn’t they help Gandalf up?

They didn’t help Gandalf because Gandalf was helping them. When Gandalf said “Fly, you fools” he wasn’t suggesting Quantas. The Balrogs were fierce and deadly enemies even of the Maiar, and far beyond the strength of all but a few of the Eldar and more than a match for any of the Kings of Men.

Is Gandalf an immortal?

As one of the Maiar he is an immortal spirit, but being in a physical body on Middle-earth, he can be killed in battle, as he is by the Balrog from Moria. He is sent back to Middle-earth to complete his mission, now as Gandalf the White and leader of the Istari.

What does Gandalf say when he died?

“Fly, you fools” is a mid 20th British equivalent to, “run like H*ll!” Given a chance later, he would probably rephrase. Gandalf appreciated heroism and loyalty, which is what the other members of the Fellowship were doing when the Balrog came up behind Gandalf.

Does Gandalf say fly or run?

The actual quote: “Fly, you fools!” I swear, whenever I try to remember this climactic scene from The Fellowship of the Ring, I hear it as “Run, you fools!” In fact in the original theatrical release Gandalf did say “run”, but in every DVD release he has been dubbed to say “fly” to more accurately reflect the dialogue …

What did Gandalf say to the Balrog?

In Moria, when Gandalf confronts the Balrog on the bridge of Khazad-dûm, Gandalf says the following: I am a servant of the Secret Fire, wielder of the flame of Anor. You cannot pass! The dark fire will not avail you, flame of Udûn.

Why can’t Gandalf touch the ring?

Gandalf can’t touch the One ring because it would corrupt him and he would become a terrifying wizard like Saruman. It’s the same reason Galadriel refused the One ring. The One ring can only be worn by Sauron. Anyone else who wields it would be under his control, even Gandalf the grey/ white.

Where did Gandalf go when he died?

4 Answers. By dying when he did, Gandalf had not completed his task of helping to defeat Sauron. In addition, his comrade Saruman had betrayed his order. And so, he was sent back to Middle-earth as Gandalf the White by Eru, the highest power in the Middle-earth universe.

Did Gandalf die?

Gandalf made him this way. In the middle of the first Lord of the Rings novel, The Fellowship of the Ring, shortly after his pronouncement on death to Frodo, Gandalf dies. “I can’t explain the impact that had on me at 13,” Martin said in a recent interview with PBS. “You can’t kill Gandalf.

Why did Gandalf leave Middle-Earth?

Someone else could probably go into a lot more detail. But I’m pretty sure Tolkien wanted Middle-Earth to be a very old Earth (as in the earth we live on), and the elves left to pass the dominion of Middle-Earth to men. Gandalf left because he is a divine/semi-divine being–basically an archangel.

Is Legolas older than Gandalf?

Legolas is older than Gandalf. Gandalf (Olorín) is a Maya Who has took the form of a wizard (Istari). If his physical form will die, as it did in the second movie, he will have a “new one”, because he is immortal. Gandalf is 2 019 years old at the time of the war of the ring.

Why did Gandalf turn white?

As the only one of the five Istari to stay true to his errand, Olórin/Gandalf was sent back to mortal lands by Eru, and he became Gandalf once again. … Gandalf was carried to Caras Galadhon in Lothlórien, where he was healed, given a new staff, and clothed in white, and thus became Gandalf the White.

Why is Gandalf so powerful?

Gandalf possesed Power of the mind and ability to influence people and great wisdom. Gandalf is the wisest of the Maiar. He was known as Olórin, who sometimes dwelt in the gardens of Irmo and was the pupil of Nienna, who taught him wisdom and pity, and of Manwë and Varda.

Why didn’t Gandalf warn the fellowship about the Balrog?

The movie implies that Gandalf knew there was a balrog in Moria and that is why he didn’t want to go that route, because they could possibly die and lose the ring. Gandalf was not aware of the massive orc presence in Moria so he could not warn them of that.

Why did Boromir stop Frodo from helping Gandalf?

He would not have been able to help Gandalf on his own, so if the bridge had collapsed while they were helping Gandalf, they would have lost at least three members of the fellowship, including Gandalf, and the One Ring, which would mean that Middle-Earth had practically lost the war with Sauron allready.

What are Gandalf’s last words?

“You cannot pass!” “”To Lorien, keep the ring and the ringbearer safe!” “Escape now, or all shall be lost!” “Fly, you fools!”

Who is better Dumbledore or Gandalf?

Gandalf is more fully fleshed-out, but as an immortal, he’s not a normal person. … Gandalf is greater than Dumbledore although (or perhaps because) he had less power. He rallied all the free peoples of Middle-Earth to the cause, gave them heart, and sacrificed himself to save his friends and the quest in Moria.

How did Saruman become evil?

Paul Kocher identifies Saruman’s use of a palantír, a seeing-stone, as the immediate cause of his downfall, but also suggests that through his study of “the arts of the enemy”, Saruman was drawn into imitation of Sauron.

Can you return from the undying lands?

Either way, they’re not coming back. Mortals are not allowed into the Undying Lands, no matter what.

Is Sauron an elf?

Originally Answered: Is Sauron an elf? No, he was a Maia of the race of the Ainur. At the beggining, when Eru created the Ainur, he created 2 types of Ainur: The Valar, that had more innate power and understood better the aspects of Eru’s mind (each one of the Valar understood different aspects of Eru’s mind).

Why did Gandalf let Frodo decide?

Gandalf is afraid; he gives the decision to Frodo as an act of surrender to his fate. The movie portrays Gandalf trying at all costs to avoid entering the Mines of Moria, instead opting for the dangerous pass of Cahadras.