Which Hobbit Movie Is Closest To The Book?

Why do goblins look different in the Hobbit?

Symmetrical eyes, specific postures, etc.

Most of the goblins in The Hobbit are CGI, this gave them more to work with, they could have grotesque features that just aren’t feasible on a human.

but orcs look basically human, not monstrous..

Did Kili die in the book?

Kili dies, no ifs, ands, or buts about it. The silver lining, especially for those who were fans of the controversial Tauriel/Kili/Legolas love triangle which was fabricated for the films, is that Kili and Tauriel do get one final scene together and it is epic.

Is the pale orc in The Hobbit book?

In The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey, Azog is the orc chieftain of Moria, and is called The Defiler or The Pale Orc.

Which hobbits die in the book?

In The Hobbit, Thorín Oakenshield has twelve companions: Fili, Kili, Dwalin, Balin, Bifur, Bofur, Bombur, Dori, Nori, Ori, Oín, and Glóin. Of these thirteen Dwarves, three die at the end of the novel in the Battle of the Five Armies: Thorín, Fili, and Kili.

What went wrong with the Hobbit?

One of the main problems in adapting The Hobbit is that Smaug the dragon doesn’t fit the mold of a modern villain, being little more than a hoarder with a bad temper. To solve the problem, Jackson’s Smaug was more vicious than his book counterpart, and this alteration worked well enough for film.

Who did Legolas marry?

TaurielTauriel truly threw a wrench in Legolas’ life when he fell in love with her. She was brave, fierce, and a protective leader of the guard. He was meant to be the dutiful son of King Thranduil, but in loving her, he became a stubborn, masterful archer instead.

What did Kili say to tauriel when he died?

Before leaving with the rest, Kili can’t help but speak his heart. He tells Tauriel goodbye, but not before pleading with her to come with him. Kili: “I know how I feel; I’m not afraid. You make me feel alive.”

Why are orcs so bad at fighting?

Orcs are greedy, selfish, disloyal, and lazy. You can expect them to fight more like rabble and less like a well-organized army. In the LOTR, orcs attack fortified positions. Man-to-man (or man-to-orc), that is a significant disadvantage.

Why is the hobbit movie so different from the book?

The reason that the Hobbit movies are so different from the books on which they are based is because they were directed and co-written by Peter Jackson and not J.R.R. Tolkien. … Peter Jackson wanted a stronger connection between The Hobbit and the LOTR trilogy, so he added in a bunch of extra scenes.

Why is Gandalf so useless?

He was forbidden to gain power or hold lordship over people or openly challenge Sauron. The wizards were sent to advise and council all the free folk. This is enough to show that you have not read the books, hehehe. … Gandalf, indeed all of the Istari were not to use their power directly.

Why do the Hobbit movies look so bad?

The Hobbit is overly saturated (and overly CGI’d) which also takes from the experience as the CGI stands out more this way, in LOTR the CGI blends in perfectly with the enviroment BECAUSE THE ENVIROMENT IS REAL so the CGI can easily be lit and rendered properly to look like it’s there but in the Hobbit a lot of the …

Does tauriel exist in the Hobbit book?

Tauriel is a fictional character from Peter Jackson’s feature film adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit. … The character does not appear in the original book, but was created by Peter Jackson, Philippa Boyens and Fran Walsh as an expansion of material adapted from the book.

Which is better the Hobbit or Lord of the Rings?

Tolkien, when he wrote The Hobbit, created a legendarium so massive that it would take hundreds of books to really deconstruct. Hundreds of books have been written about Lord of the Rings and its deeper, more philosophical meaning, or in the context of the First and Second World Wars. But, The Hobbit is a better book.

For me, The Hobbit is the best fantasy book precisely because it marks the traditional fantasy story, and all fantasy stories either borrow from it or break its rules. It’s an endearing and enduring classic, a story that like all the best fairy tales simply grows better with age.

Why is Gandalf so weak in the movies?

Gandalf seems weak because the vast majority of his power is restrained by the gods. Sticking to his oaths, he abides by what the Gods commanded of him, unlike Saruman and the other wizards.

Is Lord of the Rings a good read?

The Lord of the Rings trilogy is absolutely worth reading, even though they’re very long and a bit monotonous. There’s so much to the story that doesn’t make it into movies, side stories and fascinating tidbits that you miss if you don’t take the plunge.

Are orcs dead elves?

No. Orcs are neither dead nor undead. In the animal sense of the term, they are alive in their bodies. Tolkien tells us that Morgoth, incapable of creation, could make evil creatures by distorting and debasing good ones.

Who killed Bolg in The Hobbit?

In anger, Tauriel throws Bolg off the mountain and is dragged down with him. He is then spotted by Legolas and the two engage in a fierce duel ending with Legolas killing Bolg by stabbing a dagger through his head.

How similar is the Hobbit movie to the book?

The Hobbit movies are certainly less focused on Bilbo than the book. … The Hobbit was written as a children’s book with the ring being just a magic ring. Peter Jackson certainly had his work cut out for him trying to give The Hobbit a similar feel and making it a true prequel to the lotr epic.

How close are the Lord of the Rings movies to the books?

As movie adaptations tend to go, they are not wildly unfaithful. If you look at the “big picture”, it is about 80 % the “same” story. But if you try to zoom in on the details, there are very few (if any) scenes that play out detail by detail and line by line just as in the book.

How much of the book does the first Hobbit movie cover?

81 pages1 Answer. The first movie, An Unexpected Journey, covers chapters 1 to 6, a total of just over 81 pages in the copy I’m currently referencing. This comprises: The Unexpected Party and formation of the company.